Connect with us

Match Reviews

Barcelona player ratings vs Benfica: Awful Alba gets a 4; five players get 8 or higher

Published

on

Photo by Alex Caparros/Getty Images

Barcelona hosted Benfica at the Camp Nou for their do-or-die fixture, and against all odds, the team fell to a scoreless stalemate.

That said, the performance was undoubtedly one that left a mark on the Camp Nou faithful. The team showed intent and courage throughout the 90, and it is clear that Xavi’s ideas are being implemented slowly but successfully.

Barcelona came close to scoring several times, and if not for a monstrous performance for Nicolas Otamendi, they would have found their way through. Alas, it was not to be.

Certainly more positives than negatives from this fixture, with a less than handful questionable individual performances. Barça Universal runs the rule over the men in garnet and blue.

Marc-Andre ter Stegen: 6.5

Three saves on the night for ter Stegen, who was highly lauded as a top-3 goalkeeper in the world by Xavi. He did give away possession early on for a straightforward Benfica chance and could be criticised for being beaten too easily by Haris Seferovic in stoppage time. Lucky the Swiss squandered the opportunity, though.

Ronald Araujo: 8.5

Barcelona are almost always in for a defensive showing when Araujo takes place in the defence, and today was no different. He made five tackles and was not dribbled past a single time.

General Araujo. (Photo by Alex Caparros/Getty Images)

Moreover, he acted as an extra man in attack at times and almost scored the winner, which was eventually ruled out for offside. Injured himself while celebrating. Clumsy.

Gerard Pique: 8

A spectacular outing for Pique, who led the defence brilliantly. The Spaniard won 10/11 of his aerial duels and came very close to scoring in stoppage time through a header.

Clement Lenglet: 7

Lenglet was the weakest link in the back-three, but his performance was by no means poor. He continually stepped out of his line to intercept the ball and attempted several brave passes to cut through the Benfica backline.

Yusuf Demir: 8

Demir lost the ball 17 times on the night, but he showed something missing from the Barcelona wings this season: courage. The Austrian did not stop trying to take his marker on through the 90.

He also came oh-so-close to scoring twice – forcing a save once and hitting the woodwork another time. A few more performances like this, and Demir could truly force himself into the lineup.

Sergio Busquets: 8.5

Donning the captain’s armband for the fifth time in the Champions League this season, Busi produced arguably his best game of the season. He executed every move with perfection, feinting through the Benfica midblock.

Busquets also created three chances on the night, finding attackers with defence-splitting through balls.

Frenkie de Jong: 7

The conundrum while judging Frenkie de Jong is that everyone understands what he is capable of, so when he produces anything but perfection, it feels underwhelming. Tonight was another example of the same.

Not at his best today. (Photo by Alex Caparros/Getty Images)

The Dutchman made a piercing run through the defence early on, finding Memphis Depay for a scoring chance, but failed to impact the game fully since. He also got on the end of a cross late on but overhit his header.

Jordi Alba: 4

Despite being far from his best, Jordi Alba has been able to come up with five assists across two competitions, but it was simply not his night against Benfica. The left-back was failed to create a single chance and did not complete any of his four attempted crosses. Moreover, he missed an easy chance that could have taken Barcelona ahead.

Nico: 9

Nico is quickly becoming a fan-favourite, and it is easy to see why. The 19-year-old wears his heart on his sleeve, and he left everything on the pitch tonight.

He pressed the Benfica defence high, making several recoveries in addition to his game-high four key passes and two big chances created. Inarguably the best player on the pitch, there is more to come from Nico Gonzalez this season.

Gavi: 7

Gavi was another in today’s list of players who made poor decisions in front of goal. He was unable to finish off a chance in the first half, hitting it over the bar. Did manage to create two chances, though. An overall decent performance.

An off night for the teenager. (Photo by Alex Caparros/Getty Images)

Memphis Depay: 6

If there is one word to describe Memphis’ performance yesternight, it would be annoying. The Dutchman led the line well, making several runs behind the defence, but completely switch his functioning off during key moments.

He messed up a chance early on by overhitting a pass to de Jong, and then twice, again, due to his reluctance to shoot from his left foot. He was also caught offside thrice, and made no shots on target.

SUBSTITUTES

Ousmane Dembele: 6.5

Dembele brought speed to the attack, but did not really do an awful lot. He created one chance for de Jong, but lost the ball 15 times in 24 minutes.

Eric Garcia: N/A

Came on with four minutes to spare; barely touched the ball.

Sergino Dest: N/A

Brought on late, probably as a precautionary measure. Did not do enough to warrant a rating.

Editor-in-Chief. | A picture says a thousand words, but someone's got to write them.

5 Comments

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. weston Jinjika

    24/11/2021 at 10:47

    I think Depay is loosing focus. He is failing to make shot. Only offside . This is pathetic. We need to buy strikers guys we cn rely on Depay he is failing us. He is failing to position himself. He dont know his duty. I think

  2. Steve johnson

    24/11/2021 at 10:58

    Come on, Alba rated 4, no way, maybe a 5 or a 5.5, but certainly not a 4! As for the players that have been rated 8 or over, they are all overated. Busquets should be rated 7.5 or leniently an 8 and definately not 8.5, Araujo the same as Busquets. Nico rated a 9 is unbelievable, a 7.5 is a more realistic rating. Demir an 8 is also unbelievable, he should be rated a 7. There is a consistent overating.
    As with regards to Nico and Gavi in particular, time and time again, at least 3 ocassions for each, when they found themselves outside the box at winger positions and they did not know what to do. The ball ended up going back. Which is ok because Barca retained the ball. But it shows their limitations, they are midfield players but wide on the wings either because they are too young or because they are located out of position they show no vision and end up playing as robots. Very little passing towards the box.
    Comparing them to Dembele, of course they were great because they did not loose the ball as much, but the reason they did so was that they played it safe and their progressive passing was average. Dembele tried to put players through, with passes towards/inside the box that were much more visionary than Nico and Gavi passing backwards, and more of a gamble. He failed because he has not played much for a long time and because of that there is not much chemistry between him and players like Depay and De Jong so they can not synchronise well yet.

    • dabe

      24/11/2021 at 13:09

      Nico had the most progressive passes in the whole team just so you know.

    • Lei

      24/11/2021 at 18:46

      You are right about everything except Busquets. He was literal perfection in last 2 games, the moment he got out against Espanyol game fell apart. He is our most stable player, makes no mistakes. Somehow at this point he is doing his own role while also performing role of Xavi and Iniesta. Nico and Gavi extremely overrated, they don’t create or basically do anything, and taking ball from them is like taking candy from a toddler. Demir the same, but a bit more passionate in attack.

  3. Cristian R.

    24/11/2021 at 15:34

    Depay was BY FAR our worst player, wasting pretty much every ball that came his way. We knew going into this game that we will create not a lot, but a few scoring chances, and therefore it was crucial to be clinical in the box. Not only that Depay wasn’t, but often times he would execute corner kicks instead of being in the box.

    As this has been happening over and over again, I don’t think we can truly progress with Depay at Nr. 9, we need a real striker. Depay is all over the pitch, that is he is losing possession all over the pitch. Yes, he is the “top” scorer, but (a) this is in the context of a Barca team with poor scoring output, and (b) he wastes much more than he converts.

    Frankly, I can’t see how we can progress with him wasting so many balls, we need a real striker with a decent conversion rate, and Depay isn’t it.