Connect with us

Opinions

9 for Memphis, 0 for Messi: Rating Barcelona’s summer transfer window

Published

on

Photo via Imago

Heading into the summer, culés were filled with excitement that the squad would be rejuvenated and made anew. They expected departures of heavy-earners who were out of the picture, the resigning of Lionel Messi, and an influx of fresh faces. Two months later, Barcelona have had one of the worst transfer windows in recent memory.

The following piece will evaluate said transfer window, looking at the squad depth, rating each major departure and arrival, and analysing how it all came to be.

A Nightmare Summer

Upon reflection, one has to ask: how did this all happen? How did Barcelona lose so much and gain so little? The financial reasons behind it all can be traced to years of mismanagement and careless spending, the consequences of which were much more devastating than first expected.

Additionally, maybe it’s a problem of expectation. Maybe culés should not have expected any major moves or departures. But, the fact that they only “sold” one heavy-earner and brought in one player in his prime is telling too about what’s going on behind the scenes.

Hopefully, it is all a severe case of temporary pain for future success.

Going by position, let’s take a look at the team’s depth and quality at the end of the transfer window. In other words, what is the squad makeup now?

In between the goalposts, the combination of Marc-Andre ter Stegen and Neto remains untouched and a solid pairing. 

At centre-back, the Blaugrana (disappointingly) added no world-class options, only the young and promising Eric Garcia. Despite Ronald Araujo’s expected improvements and hopefully a bounce-back season from Clement Lenglet, the defence is still levels below where it should be in order to compete with Europe’s best.

Araujo is expected to lead the defence into the new era. (Photo via Imago)

Emerson Royal was a smart and high-value addition at right-back, adding more quality and quantity, but his sudden departure is short-sighted. The team is now bare at full-back with only Sergiño Dest, Jordi Alba, and Sergi Roberto. His signing meant Barça did not have to worry about the right-back position after years of turmoil. Now, it’s back to square one.  

There were no major arrivals nor departures in midfield, although there is an influx of youngsters – Gavi and Nico Gonzalez – who will make an impact this season. 

Upfront, Barça saw a lot of changes. Out were Lionel Messi, Francisco Trincao, and shockingly Antoine Griezmann; in came Memphis Depay, Sergio Aguero, Yusuf Demir, and the last-minute acquisition of Luuk de Jong. The return of Ansu Fati can not come soon enough.

Looking at each individual arrival and departure, there is plenty to unpack. The following (arrival) ratings are based on what the player can bring to the team, how financially sound the move was, and how their first few weeks as a Blaugrana have gone. For the departures, similar factors are taken into account, such as transfer fees and whether they should have been let go or not.

Arrivals

Memphis Depay

A dream start. (Photo via Imago)

While only a few weeks into the season, Depay has exceeded all expectations. The Dutchman has hit the ground running, scoring twice in his first three appearances. He is fitting into the team with ease, and without Messi (or Griezmann), he has to take on the mantle. 

The only reason he has not scored a perfect 10/10 is because there is still a lot of football to be played. 

Rating: 9/10 

Eric Garcia

Another free signing, Eric Garcia, returned home after a four-year spell at Manchester City. Only 20-years old, he is one for the future but performed admirably in his debut. His second match (versus Athletic Bilbao), on the other hand, was a long and hard night.

There is no pressure on Garcia to alleviate all of the squad’s defensive issues, however, hopefully, he can work on fulfilling his immense potential. 

Rating: 8/10 

Yusuf Demir

On loan from Rapid Wien, Demir has impressed with Barcelona thus far. As a creative and nifty number 10, the 18-year old can become a major part of the Catalans’ future after the departure of Griezmann and be the bearer of the #11 jersey for the next several years.

Rating: 8/10 

Sergio Aguero

 Naturally, Aguero’s rating doesn’t take into account his performances – as he’s yet to make his debut. Still, judging his age and squad role, it is a welcome signing. 

Rating: 6/10 

Luuk de Jong

A signing that makes little sense, Luuk de Jong was brought in on deadline day to offer a new dimension upfront. He brings a lot to the table as a target man but little else. 

Rating: 3/10 

Departures

Lionel Messi 

This will always hit the eye differently. (Photo via Imago)

The biggest shock of the summer was undoubtedly Messi’s departure. After taking for granted his probable renewal, the entire footballing world was shot in the heart when Barcelona revealed he would be leaving the club. This move can’t be justified and thus deserved its rating. 

Rating: 0/10 

Antoine Griezmann

After two underwhelming seasons, Griezmann’s story with Barcelona has finally come to an end – for now. Giving Atletico Madrid more firepower will only hurt the Catalans’ title-winning chances, but the move helps them financially, so it’s a departure that is difficult to judge. 

Rating: 5/10 

Ilaix Moriba

If you asked anyone a few months ago whether they thought Moriba would leave Barcelona, they would have given an immediate “no”. Losing out on such talent is never a good thing, but to be fair, the youngster wanted to leave. Therefore, it was a solid move.

Rating: 7/10

Emerson Royal

Much like other players on this list, Emerson’s departure came out of nowhere. Sure the Brazillian did not particularly impress during his first few appearances, however, he still could offer plenty more to the team. Additionally, the move is not financially beneficial as Barça will end up securing only around €3 million when considering his the total amount they paid for them and the sell-on clause Real Betis imposed.

Rating: 4/10

Junior Firpo

Firpo is the story of another full-back who was not up to par for the Blaugrana standards. Letting the left-back go was a smart move for all parties involved, even if it means Barça lack a backup to Jordi Alba. Luckily, Dest and youngster Alejandro Balde can step in.

Rating: 8/10

Francisco Trincao

Barcelona should have, in hindsight, kept Trincao. (Photo via Imago)

After one year and only a handful of meaningful appearances, Trincao was swiftly shipped to England to play with the Wolves. From one perspective, the winger admittedly failed to make a mark with the Catalans. On the other hand, he was never given a valid run of games to establish form and deserved another season to prove himself. The talent is clear as day, albeit an unpolished one.

Rating: 4/10

Jean-Claire Todibo

After a few seasons out on loan, Todibo has finally found a home at OGC Nice. The young centre-back could never quite break into a Barcelona side that needed his services. In all, it’s another move that helps both parties.

Rating: 7/10

Any room for optimism?

It feels like things just get darker and darker for Barcelona. The truth is, the metaphorical light at the end of the tunnel feels impossible to find. Still, with their backs against the wall, the team has no way to go but onwards and up.

The transfer window may not have set up Barça for a promising season, but it is still a squad full of promising talent and players who want to prove themselves.

Overall rating: 6/10

Throughout my life of constant change, one thing has never faltered: my love for FC Barcelona. Whether through watching every game, listening to pundits, or playing FIFA and Football Manager, I've always wanted an outlet to express my passion for the team. Barça Universal gives me the perfect opportunity to do so, as I can combine my love of writing with my love of Barça and the sport.

1 Comment

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Steve johnson

    01/09/2021 at 14:39

    Moriba would have left, it was on the cards, the moment Koeman critised him on his wage demands it was over. One cannot pay millions to players like Dembele, Griezman, Umtiti etc that are offering minimal to the team efford and treat probably talented players that maybe the club future in such a way! History will say if Moriba was right to leave, but Moriba seems to be a gutsy player and character that will probably do well. Rating should be 4/10 for the Moriba sale! He might have stayed if he was given an increased contract or a shorter extension.

    Griezmann sale rating should have been 0! Lets see what happened. Barca pay 120mil for Griez in 2019. The payment plus the additional funds spend for his salary are the penultimate nail in the coffin for Barca debt/finansial issues. Last year because of the finansial issues Barca “gift” Suarez to Athleti and Athleti win La Liga. Then with further debt issues this year Athleti wait patiently. If they had loaned Griez a couple of months ago maybe Barca would have found a way for Messi to remain so Athleti wait and after Messi is gone to PSG they go for the loan. Yes the wages Athleti will pay are too high (but also leverage) but they are probably now looking at back to back la liga titles! After Athleti win la liga again they will probably return Griez to Barca (so that Barca continue paying his high salary. Or will convince Griez to take a 50% basic wages cut (with performance related bonuses) and keep him for only 40mil. Rating 0 for Barca, 10 fir Athleti!