Connect with us


What if…Pep Guardiola had never coached Barcelona?

Prajas Naik



Header Image by Imago

After having imagined what would have happened if Di Stéfano had joined Barcelona instead of Madrid, we ask ourselves: what if Pep Guardiola had never coached the blaugranas?

Those unforgettable El Clásico victories, that late Iniesta goal, the legendary 2009 Sextuple, the beautiful Positional Play style of play and, of course, those legendary Lionel Messi goals. They send all culés back to a time when the team was on top of the world with one of the best and most successful sides the world had ever seen. They remind us of the golden days when Barcça were unbeatable. All those memories had one architect, who took the club to heights never seen before. That man was Pep Guordiola, one of the most influential managers in Barcelona history. But what if Pep had never joined the first team? What if Pep had never taken the reins? 

Pep was promoted to the senior side in 2008, replacing Frank Rijkaard, with the club having gone two years without a trophy. His arrival changed things drastically, with the club winning their first treble – Champions League, La Liga and Copa del Rey – and a record-breaking six trophies in the calendar year of 2009. The Catalan was the most successful coach in Barcelona history with 14 trophies in total to his name. But it was the manner in which he achieved success that really put the cherry on top of the cake. His beautiful attacking football could easily dismantle even the best sides and at times left even the opposition managers in awe. It was his tactics, his transfers and his mentality that transformed Barça.

Without Guardiola, the blaugranas would have been left in a confusing state with the ageing squad in dire need of trophies. He took risks by offloading legends such as Deco, Ronaldinho and Zambrotta whilst bringing in Dani Alves and Gerard Piqué, who went on to become legends for the club. Risks that few managers would opt to take. His 4–3–3 and later 3–4–3 diamond had its roots in Cruyff’s style of play, but Pep built on it, using his squad to maximum capacity. No manager could have replicated Guardiola’s incredible tactics and immaculate squad balance.

Pep Guardiola coached Barcelona

Pep Guardiola’s influence at Barcelona goes far beyond any result | Photo by Imago

With his approach on the ball already excellent, he revolutionised Barcelona off the ball. His six-second rule often bolstered Barça against counter-attacks and helped to regain possession. It was Pep’s genius which led the azulgranas to maintain attacking play without suffering on the defensive side too much, a trait the recent Barcelona sides are lacking. Guardiola found the tactical solution to breaking down all the best sides in Europe. He introduced a new style of play which no other manager had seen before, rendering them defenceless as Barcelona destroyed their enemies.

But perhaps his greatest achievement was his influence on the players. He mentored Messi, adding finesse to his raw talent. He unleashed the Argentinian’s full potential and shaped him into possibly the greatest player the world has ever seen. Leo had already announced himself to the world, but it was under Pep that he truly matured. His decision to play Messi as a false 9 was a masterstroke, taking advantage of his creativity, vision and goalscoring ability. Busquets adopted the role of the midfield pivot and has gone on to become one of the best holding midfielders ever. Iniesta and Xavi developed a lethal combination with Messi given their perfect passing and awareness, while Piqué, Alves and Pedro developed into the best in their positions.

❛ The best team I have ever faced ❜

Sir Alex Ferguson
after Barcelona’s 3–1 victory over Manchester United in the 2011 Champions League final

In a world without Pep Guardiola, it is quite possible Barcelona would have still gone on to become successful given the boatloads of talent in their squad and the presence of the talismanic Leo Messi. But more than the silverware, it was Pep’s contribution to Barcelona’s philosophy that would have been affected the most in his absence. He built on Cruyffian principles and gave Barcelona a refined and, frankly speaking, a gorgeous identity. An identity that every culé identifies with and one which would have been dearly missed. He gave the football community a side that was an absolute joy to watch, and left legends like Sir Alex Ferguson stunned. He developed players unlike anyone else and helped bring out their hidden prospects. His eye for talent is irreplaceable. Maybe Barcelona would have become the best even in a world without Pep, or maybe they would have gone on a downhill until the next great manager had come along. But I do know one thing for sure. I am glad I grew up in a world where Guordiola was at the helm.

See also

• What if…Di Stéfano had joined Barcelona instead of Madrid?

Barcelona, it’s time to bet on potential

• Moussa Wagué and a season of only 8 games

• Lionel Messi: Perfecting the role of the false 9

• Aleñá and Riqui Puig, finally trusted by Barça?

Football is something that comes from within. Every minute spent watching or playing the beautiful game brings out emotions in ways nothing else ever could. This emotion embodied itself in FC Barcelona for me. Every piece I read or write, every moment I watch just multiplies my love for the club. The ability of being able to express this craze of mine is a remarkable gift for me. Its a gift that never stops giving.



Josep Samitier, the artist and hero of Barcelona’s first golden age

Amal Ghosh



Header Image by FC Barcelona

Josep Samitier was a surrealist artist on and off the pitch and a legendary midfielder that brought Barcelona its first successful era in the 1920s, as well as some controversy throughout his career.

Surrealism, a deceptive interrogation of reality that transcends the human subconscious to manipulate or alter the coherent understanding of existence. Josep Samitier Vilalta, or “L’home llagosta” (The lobster man) was the most surreal portrait in the history of FC Barcelona. He was called the ‘surrealista’, because his genius produced the illusions on the pitch that were perplexing to fathom as reality.

History is constructed up on the interdependency of figures and events. Samitier was one of those figures who created a rift in the annals of world football to produce the first reverberation of football in the streets of Barcelona. The footballing revolution in Catalonia peaked in the early 1920s, especially in Barcelona, as it was the beginning of the first golden age.

With the construction of the Les Corts stadium, the club assembled a group of talented, young players. Josep Samitier, along with Paulino Alcántara, Ricardo Zamora, Emili Sagi-Barba, Vicenç Piera and Agustín Sancho became the first generation of the club idols. Samitier, among others, was an integral part of Barcelona’s rebuilding of character and went on to become one of the most significant personalities both in terms of sporting and cultural relevance.

Samitier was born on 2nd February 1902 in a Catalan working-class family. As a young boy in the streets of Barcelona where the roads of passion and dreams lead to the grant Les Corts, ‘El Sami’ would kick the ball around waving at the passing commons.

After the club’s establishment, FC Barcelona had quite an attachment with the proletarian class. Especially at the time of industrial unrest, the institution always kept them close and the stadium was always packed with the same working-class populace. Young minds like Samitier who would grow up in the streets of Barcelona always had the ball on their feet and club in their heart.

Samitier started playing for FC Internacional before making his debut for Barcelona at the age of 17 in 1919. The club museum still preserves and cherishes his signing bonuses, a shimmering watch and a three-piece suit. By 1925, Samitier became the highest-paid player at the club and thus became the highest-earning player in the country.

The division of labour was evident in the early years of European football. Whilst the backline remained static to protect the goal, the forward line had to pick and fight the battle on their own. Samitier was among the key figures who created a paradigm shift from this prevailing ‘Basque style’, where the attackers held the sole responsibility to win the ball and navigate their own way to find a goal. Samitier was among the first players to orchestrate the game from the back. He was like a master of the opera performance where he controlled and navigated the rhythm and flow of the game.

Emili Sagi-Barba Vicenç Piera Josep Samitier Barcelona

Josep Samitier (middle), alongside teammates Emili Sagi-Barba (left) and Vicenç Piera (right) from the successful Barcelona team of the 1920s | Photo by FC Barcelona

Samitier was an exceptional player who could manipulate the ball like a wizard, and he dribbled the ball around the pitch like a ballet dancer. He was the first midfielder general in the history of Spanish football, whose role was the hybrid between a Pivote (central midfielder) and the Leñero (chopper) or sweeper. Samitier was the harbinger of the modern-day box-to-box role. Despite being positioned in a deep-lying role, Samitier was an outstanding goalscorer. It was rather unusual for a midfielder of that time to score an astonishing 184 goals for any club in Europe.

Even though Barcelona was graced with many prolific players, Samitier was the core of the magnificent Barça team of the 1920s. He would hack the ball from the opposition to carry the ball from the midfield to provide a line-breaking pass in the final third. His glorious days at Les Corts were filled with thrilling langosta (lobster) kicks which would eventually evolve into the modern ‘chilena’ or bicycle-kick. Samitier was an entertainer on the pitch. His ostentatious performance attracted the Catalans into the stadium.

His glittering thirteen years in a blaugrana shirt were decorated with 11 Catalan Championships, 5 Spanish Championships and the first Spanish league that began in 1928. Moreover, his time with Barça was embellished with title-winning goals in the Copa del Rey finals of 1922, 1925, 1926 and 1928.

Pepe Samitier’s momentous career at Barcelona transformed him from a sporting figure to a cultural icon in Catalan society. His reputation at the club produced a strong political outline for himself among the intellectuals in the society. It was an unprecedented period in the socio-cultural scenario of Europe. The entrée of subjective art and understanding by Salvador Dalí, Edvard Munch and Vincent van Gogh among other artistic prominence overtook the existing concepts of impressionism and naturalism.

Samitier aligned with surrealism, indulging the spirit of subjectivity. He reflected this both in the game and in his outside loyalties. His acquaintances mostly consist of radical artists and political figures of the time, including the tango maestro Carlos Gardel, Mauricio Chevalier, Salvador Dalí and, in contrast to his idol figure in Catalonia, he also had a close relationship with the dictator Franco.

In 1933, after a dramatic feud with the Barcelona management, an ageing El Sami dropped from the first team. Real Madrid, then called Madrid CF, took advantage of this dispute and were able to convince him to join the club. However, it was his secret allegiance with General Franco that helped Madrid to accomplish the operation.

Even though his short stint at Madrid wasn’t really celebrated, Samitier did guide them to win the La Liga title in 1932/33 and the Copa de España in 1934. But he played a significant role for Madrid, not as a player but as a super-agent in a decade-defining transfer of Alfredo Di Stéfano, whose intended destination was Barcelona. This signing was the inflexion point for Madrid in the 1960s, as Di Stéfano would go on to score 216 goals and play an important role in their European domination. Although Samitier’s allegiance with General Franco was visible, this transfer saga threw the relationship open into society.

Alfredo Di Stéfano Real Madrid Josep Samitier Barcelona

Real Madrid’s signing of Alfredo Di Stéfano (right) changed Real Madrid’s history forever | Photo by Staff / AFP via Getty Images

Before the Spanish civil war burst out in 1936, Samitier spent a brief time in managing Atlético de Madrid, succeeding Fred Pentland in the middle of the season, but failed to keep them in the first division. Nonetheless, the season was scrapped as soon as the civil war started and Samitier, who had strong ties with the nationalist side, found himself blacklisted and arrested by the anarchist militia.

Eventually, he was released by the militia and fled to France. His exile to France was later utilized by the Franco regiment to spread the anti-communist propaganda by portraying this event in a film titled ‘The Stars Search for Peace’, where Samitier enacted himself. During his time in France, Samitier joined OGC Nice as a player, where he would unite with his old teammate Zamora. He went onto score 47 goals in 82 matches. In 1939, he retired as a footballer and briefly managed OGC Nice in 1942.

After two years and 8 months, the civil war ended and the nationalists alliance under General Franco demolished the second Spanish republic to establish the new Spanish state. Josep Samitier returned to Spain in 1944, and he took charge of Barcelona. His homecoming was celebrated as he guided Barcelona to win their second-ever La Liga title in 1945 and lifted the Copa de Oro Argentina by beating the Copa del Generalísimo winners Athletic Club de Bilbao.

Subsequently, Samitier became the chief scout of the club and his keen vision in recognising the talent resulted in the discovery and recruitment of Ladislao Kubala, a player who went on to become a legend at Barcelona. The recruitment of Kubala was the status redemption for Samitier, who had lost its shine after the Di Stéfano transfer saga.

In 1972, Samitier rested his soul and left his showmanship and sorcery to cherish in the memories of Catalans. Despite serving Madrid and his close relationship with General Franco, he was given an honourable state funeral as a Catalan hero. Samitier was the most symbolic player in the history of the club. His close affiliation with both the cultural and sporting context of Barcelona formed an irrevocable stature of him in the Catalan society.

Samitier, as a footballing visionary, is a reference to the modern-day midfielders and, on the other hand, he was an imperative cultural icon who embraced a revolutionary socio-cultural movement in his life. Samitier’s journey from being an ambitious boy in the streets of Barcelona to a footballing legend remains one of the inspiring and reviving narrative in the history of the game. Even today, walking down the Josep Samitier Street, one could still gather an enigmatic chanting celebrating the greatest artist in the history of Barcelona.

Continue Reading

Trending Articles