Connect with us

Opinions

Laurent Blanc to Barça rumors: is he a good manager fit?

Alexandre Patanian

Published

on

Photo by NICOLAS TUCAT/AFP via Getty Images

Rumors are linking ex-PSG manager, Laurent Blanc, with his former side Barça and this appointment might do more harm than good.

It’s a lovely July afternoon; you’re sitting down on the beach and check your phone to see if anything new has appeared on it and find a rumor linking a somewhat great coach linked to your club. A great coach? Yes, a champion as a player and as a manager. “Wow, that’s amazing!” That’s what most Barça and neutral fans would think of the appointment of World Cup winner Laurent Blanc as a coach. After all, the former Manchester United and Barça defender coached some top teams, including his Bordeaux side of 2009 that won the league, France in 2012, and PSG from 2013 to 2016, winning four league titles in the meantime.

The Frenchman possesses many assets, such as his pedigree as a player and a manager and his history as a winner. Having played for the biggest clubs on the planet, especially Barcelona as he’s linked with them, the former defender warrants some degree of respect as a coach, and one would think he’d have the respect greats such as Luis Enrique, Pep Guardiola, and Didier Deschamps have. After all, there aren’t many coaches that can gloat their players’ medals and remember them for life, but Blanc can show his 2000 European Championship medal and his 1998 World Cup winner medal and celebrate.

As a coach, he seemingly has had some kind of success, with Paris and Bordeaux. Indeed, while his France side lacked in many aspects of the game and crashed out of the 2012 Euro’s against Spain in the quarter-finals, his Bordeaux side, where Yoann Gourcuff was the star, was outstanding. En route to their first Ligue 1 title in 10 years, Les Girondins smashed pre-QSI Paris, beat Lyon, ending their reign of seven league titles in a row and ground out many results. Laurent Blanc assembled a beautiful squad, and he received a lot of credits as his first managerial job helped him get the French position. With Paris, he had the best team in the league and was given a war chest to play in a league where money did not dominate yet. He won the league in his three years in charge, something his successor Unai Emery did not do.

If Laurent Blanc gets the job at Barça, there are some positives, but also many negatives come into play. First, he has difficulties in fighting egos, and when the going gets tough, he will experience acute pressure to keep his job, something the Qatari owners did to him a lot. His PSG side was controversial, and it wasn’t only the players causing troubles. It began with Leonardo, director of football at PSG at the time, and recently reappointed, who decided to elbow a referee and cause his own sacking in the process. Then, it was star man Zlatan Ibrahimovic who insulted France, by saying it’s a “sh*t country” after a disagreement with a referee. After that, it was Serge Aurier’s turn to cause havoc on the Parisian group by saying that his coach sucked Zlatan’s genitals and saying Blanc is a “p*ssy” live on Twitter. His PSG side was a lot, perhaps too controversial and it cost the former Barça player many sleepless nights as he tried to solve that.

laurent blanc psg ibrahimovic
Photo by PASCAL POCHARD-CASABIANCA/AFP via Getty Images

Honestly, it’s no wonder that Blanc hasn’t coached since getting sacked in 2016, three months after signing a contract extension that would keep him for three more seasons. Everyone mistreated and caused Blanc unparalleled stress, if he is to come to his former side, he’d probably feel forced to oblige to each and everyone’s desires. So basically, the board would sack Valverde, a yes man, for Setién, who hasn’t lived up to expectations and seems to have crumbled underneath the players’ peer pressure and then sack Setién for Blanc, who can’t command a dressing room for toffee. All that in the space of seven months, not even a year.

Also, the dressing room aside, Blanc isn’t much better tactically speaking than his predecessors. Between him, Valverde and Setién, the best tactician would be Ernesto, who adapted really well to a squad in complete crisis. Blanc is the man who could not keep a 3-1 lead against Demba Ba’s Chelsea and let’snot forget about the horrible 3-5-2, with Gregory Van Der Wiel as a right-winger, against Manchester City in a Champions League quarter-final. PSG fans hated Blanc, as they began to grow tired of not reaching the Champions League semi-finals while spending a few hundreds of millions in the summer transfer windows. They hated his style and his lack of charisma, especially when they needed to show confidence in the critical moments in the Champions League. Planning a squad and seeing out a game isn’t Blanc’s forte either.

We’re in February 2015, Paris trail Lyon in the title race and are in dire need of points to win the league. Against Caen at the Parc Des Princes, it should be a walk in the park for the Parisians and if seemed as if they would run with the win as two early goals came for them. Yohan Cabaye went off injured, as did Marquinhos at half time. After that Blanc decided to make a third sub, but he got surprised by Serge Aurier and Lucas Moura being subbed off due to injury. With nine men, Paris threw the game away, and it was all Blanc’s fault as late Emiliano Sala and Hervé Bazile’s strikes helped Caen get the draw off the reigning champions. This match was the archetype of Blanc’s Parisian career as it looked good at first, but he’d always mess up somewhere. Whether it was in a meaningless game or a Champions League knockout round, Blanc didn’t seem to know what he did.

However, with all these shortcomings, Blanc is still a title winner, with minnows Bordeaux or giants PSG and he would perhaps get Barça on top of the league again, and that’s a good start at least. Hopefully, the board makes the best decision for the club and the manager, whether it is Setién, Kluivert, or Blanc, and they shall not rush into things.

As a Lebanese teenager who never had the chance to support their local team, I fell in love with the club that was FC Barcelona at the start of the decade. I always was passionate about writing and this is exactly what I am looking for: sharing my insights and opinions on football.

Advertisement

Opinions

Braithwaite is the weapon Barcelona must keep in their arsenal

Avatar

Published

on

Photo by Sergei SUPINSKY / AFP

When Martin Braithwaite arrived for €18 million from Leganés to Barcelona, the Danish forward was unknown, his move critiqued, his transfer laughed at. Barcelona were allowed to sign him following the long term injury to Ousmane Dembele courtesy of a ‘joker window’ rule in La Liga.

Nine months later, Braithwaite is still a Blaugrana, and has, somehow, managed to earn the legendary ‘9’ jersey! With Luis Suarez departing to Atlético Madrid for peanuts, Braithwaite has remained Barcelona’s only striker option. But where does this equation head?

Braithwaite’s history since his move to Barcelona can be defined with one word: Surprise. Predicted to have no place in the team, a useless transfer and low-tier striker, Braithwaite has positively surprised angered Culés. Predicted to continue the hilarious legacy of Kevin-Prince Boateng who left after a six-month long loan, Braithwaite has comfortably overwhelmed fans.

Coming on as a substitute for Griezmann in the 72nd minute for Antoine Griezmann against Eibar on February 22nd, Braithwaite assisted both Lionel Messi and Arturo Vidal when Barcelona won 5-0 against Eibar. 

It seemed like the perfect way to start. After all, Leganés is not Barcelona. In fact, they were 19th, a place above last when Braithwaite’s transfer was made official. However, Braithwaite failed to impress in Barcelona’s 2-0 defeat against Real Madrid. But then, he scored one goal against Mallorca a month later. He didn’t play regularly, though – and rightly so, he was never supposed to be a starter.

Despite getting more and more playtime towards the end of the season, Braithwaite’s importance reduced, eventually linking him with a departure. Fans wanted him out, not understanding why he should stay there. Talks multiplied in the media; Braithwaite was going to leave in the summer. A move never materialized and Braithwaite stayed.

Suarez moved to Atlético, and suddenly, Braithwaite was Barcelona’s only striker, to the general surprise. Not only was he the only striker, but he also received Suarez’s jersey number. 

Braithwaite stayed, but Sétien did not. Ronald Koeman arrived at the helm to lead the club, and Braithwaite’s future went bleak. He was not a positive surprise anymore, but the forgotten one.

Against Getafe, in mid-october that Braithwaite finally played his first game of the season, coming off the bench for ten minutes. Games followed, but the 29-year-old did not manage to get more than ten minutes per game, often coming on around the 80th minute. 

However, his performance against Dynamo Kyiv might motivate Koeman to give the Danish striker more chances. Not only was this his first start of the season, but also the second time he was on the pitch for the entire 90 for Barcelona.

When the lineup was announced, his inclusion over Ousmane Dembele and Antoine Griezmann was questioned, but he ended the game with two goals and an assist. Not to mention, he won the penalty kick which he eventually converted.

It is no exaggeration that the forgotten Danish forward is back to the heart of the topic: Does Barcelona need off the ball runners like Braithwaite, especially when players like Griezmann or Philippe Coutinho fail to perform?

His heatmap against Dynamo Kyiv suggests so. Contrary to Griezmann, Braithwaite does not need the ball to accomplish his work. Whilst Lionel Messi, Coutinho and Griezmann all earn record-high salaries, Braithwaite is a modest player. However, he has a presence in the box that neither of Griezmann or Coutinho have, and that is what he brings to the table. Multiple times could the Braithwaite be seen running to catch what could have been an assist. 

Unless Barcelona get to have a proper #9, it’s probably best to keep Braithwaite. In Koeman’s system, a striker is needed, and Braithwaite might be a solution at times. Whilst it seems unlikely for him to start regularly, Koeman should review his options and re-consider his stance on Braithwaite.

Barcelona do not need superstars, they need modest players, and Braithwaite is one of them. Before rushing to conclusions, it is best if the Danish international is given more chances, and hopefully not in the form of a Stan Lee-cameo each game, for yesterday he proved what he can bring to the table — relentless running, a predatory instinct, and a never-dying attitude.

Continue Reading