Connect with us

Analysis

Making Sense of the Goldman Sachs Loan to Barcelona

Anurag Agate

Published

on

Photo by JOSEP LAGO/AFP via Getty Images

Despite being one of the biggest clubs in the world, FC Barcelona ended last season in a loss. Following that, a loan taken from Goldman Sachs is such that it will negatively impact the next Presidency and possibly even beyond.


As the 2019/20 season ended, FC Barcelona published their annual financial report where losses of €97 million (£88m/$114m) for the 2019-20 economic year were reported. Apart from this, Barcelona said they expected a record-breaking €1 billion revenue had it not been for the global pandemic but ended with a reported earnings of €203m (£184m/$239m) decrease in revenue. Following that, a loan taken from investment banking firm Goldman Sachs is such that it will negatively affect the next Barcelona presidency or even beyond.

Recently in an interview with EFE, Marc Ciria claimed that the COVID-19 situation is actually not the only reason for the worrying financial situation. Marc Ciria is the founding partner and general director of Diagonal Inversiones, an entity which specializes in asset management. During Joan Laporta’s 2015 candidacy for Barcelona president, Ciria was in-charge of finances and claims that the recent loan is not for the Espai Barca project and is instead being used to pay the salaries. The Espai Barca, of course, is a project which the club has invested heavily. Apart from the new stadium, it consists of developing the neighbouring Les Cortes neighbourhood as well as upgrading club infrastructures.

According to Ciria, Barcelona have taken a loan from Goldman Sachs for the Espai Barca Project and are instead diverting the funds to pay for the players’ salary. The Goldman Sachs Group is one of the biggest banking and investment management firms in the world. As it stands, Barcelona are currently entertaining a humongous wage bill of €218,892,000. A huge amount of debt is also accompanying this wage bill. In the recent financial report, the Catalans state that the debt has increased from €217m in June 2019 to €488m in June 2020.

The Barcelona board has displayed shambolic financial management throughout their term. (Photo by JOSEP LAGO/AFP via Getty Images)

The Espai Barca project is one that spreads across decades, and the fact that the funds allocated to it are being diverted raises some concerns. If Barcelona are unable to pay these loans, Goldman Sachs will be reimbursed in some other way. As Ciria says, Goldman Sachs is an investment bank and not a loan providing bank like La Caixa or BBVA. Barcelona have been unable to go to the national banks for this loan, because of the pre-existing crushing debt that they owe the national banks.

While it makes little sense in terms of financial security for the national banks, for Goldman, however, it’s a good opportunity since they are charging interest. If Barcelona are unable to repay the firm, it will put them ahead of the players in terms of monetary priority.

Goldman Sachs is not known for lending money, but rather for entering companies and then exiting them by reselling the shares it has purchased. 

Marc Cira

The Spanish economist also says that there are two scenarios this deal could proceed towards. First, Barcelona could become a sports corporation or second, an international investment fund could enter the picture, resulting in Goldman Sachs or their partners becoming 30-40% owners.

This would mean that their representatives or whoever their stake is sold to, will most likely have a say in the decisions of the club, and not all of them will have the club’s best interest at heart. Exactly the type of thing that could result in southwards development.

Before the coronavirus appeared, the club already owed 740 million euros and with it it has risen to 820. The main problem is that it is short-term debt.

Marc Cira

The financial situation doesn’t add up positively, any way you look at it. FC Barcelona have reported a loss, the wage bill is huge, and their debt is increasing. So for the Catalans to actually think this deal makes sense, it would mean that they think that an increasing debt can be paid off while simultaneously sustaining Barcelona’s status as a top club and also continuing to pay the wage bill. This is highly unlikely, which could result in massive alterations.

What next?

This loan and debt together mean that the Espai Barca project would be much more difficult for the next presidency. The current administration would have nothing to do with the club once their tenure ends. It’s their successors who would face major problems.

Barcelona being unable to pay off the loans would mean that the players are now second to Goldman Sachs. Paying-off the investment firm would become the priority. This could result in players having to leave for much less than their value and in the worst case, players being forced out to balance the wages.

According to Ciria, the next board will be unable to pay off the loan in the current state. It will need additional financing, and the project will have to be converted into something much cheaper. This might lead to just the of refurbishing the stadium. He further states that for 10 or 15 years the club will have to push aside building the Nou Palau Blaugrana and the rest of the infrastructures.

Possible solution

The wage bill is one of the biggest problem, if not the biggest. To handle that, along with the debts, two things can be done. First, promote from within, play La Masia players – 60% of the squad will have to be composed of players from the academy to ensure that the transfers and wages don’t wreak havoc. It would also mean that the current loan will have to be renegotiated with the national banks. It’s almost impossible to pay it off in the short term, so it will have to be spread over a longer period.

It might be time for La Masia to step up – necessarily so. (Photo by David Ramos/Getty Images)

Secondly, and hopefully, evitable, Barcelona would have to cut down on their staff. More than 150 employees out of 540 could lose their jobs because of this financial recklessness by the board. They managed to make the wrong decisions and prioritize financial aspects over sporting aspects for a long time now. This, however, has progressed into such a poor scenario, that it is highly unlikely to be a mistake.

18, living in India, obsessed with Barcelona and Spanish football. I am into football in any form: watching, playing, reading about, writing about...In particular, I'm very interested in youth football, especially La Masía. I try to learn more about the tactical side of football as well.

Advertisement
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Analysis

Barcelona vs Ferencvaros: The Game through Numbers

Soumyajit Bose

Published

on

Photo by LLUIS GENE / AFP

A detailed look into the game by numbers and statistics and tactics as FC Barcelona kicked off their UCL 2020-21 campaign in style.


FC Barcelona played the first group stage game of UCL 2020-21 at home against recent Hungarian champions Ferencvarosi Torna Club, also called Ferencvaros. The Budapest outfit were playing against Barcelona in a competitive match for the very first time (previous meetings had all been friendlies), and naturally, Barcelona started cautiously. However, shaking off the rust from the International break and the disappointment of the loss against Getafe in the weekend, Barcelona came up with a dominant display and ran out as winners scoring five and conceding just one.

Team Structures

Barcelona yet again fielded a 4-2-3-1, with an unchanged defence from the game against Getafe. The double-pivot changed slightly, with Miralem Pjanic starting as Frenkie de Jong’s partner. Ansu Fati and Francisco Trincāo started as wingers flanking Philipe Coutinho at attacking midfield, with Lionel Messi starting as the false 9.

The touch-based heatmaps and the pass-map show some interesting tactical changes from the last two league games. First of all, and most importantly, this was the first time this season that both flanks were very well utilised. Having Trincao and Fati, both adept at playing on the wing, greatly helped the team build and attack through both sides.

While Antoine Griezmann added a lot of defensive cover while playing on the right flank in the previous games, Trincao did his share to help out the team, too. He did well in attack while also putting in a brilliant defensive shift – Griezmann’s absence was not felt at all.

Secondly, the positioning of Frenkie de Jong was a lot advanced, bringing the best out of him. Unlike the last two games, where he was placed much deeper and wider on average, last night he had more freedom to venture up and also drift a bit centrally. On average, he took up a higher position than Pjanic and took part in a lot of the attacking moves, while the Bosnian was tasked with the deeper progressions.

Ferencvaros started out in a 4-2-3-1 as well, but soon evolved into a 4-1-4-1/4-5-1 structure and settled into it for the game. Their midfield was very compact, and mostly stayed deep. Their idea was to use counters, with Tokmak Chol Nguen the only player taking up advanced positions to lead their attacks.

Attacks and Buildups

Barcelona posted very impressive attacking stats for the game.

Barcelona dominated possession as usual, but the biggest positive takeaway are the pressing numbers. The Blaugranas posted impressive PPDA (Passes per Defensive Action) numbers as compared to their opposition. It also indicates that a lot of the game was played in the opposition’s half, showing dominance in the game. The shot maps and the xG flowcharts show how imperative Barcelona were throughout the game, and that a lot of the shots were excellent chances to score.

Next we take a look a gallery of all the goals scored by Barcelona, and the lone goal scored by Ferencvaros to discuss the difference in ideologies of the two teams.

While Barcelona’s first goal took a came solely as a result of moments of individual brilliance by Messi, all of the other goals came through wonderful intricate buildup. Both sets of wide players were very well-utilized, who were able to play out through pressure no matter where the buildup started.

The buildup to the second goal culminated in a wonderful lofted pass by Frenkie de Jong to Ansu Fati, who slotted it past Ferencvaros’ hapless goalkeeper with a first-time finish. Fati was involved in the third goal as well. An intricate set up of passes in the final third led to Messi finding Fati with a pass, who back-flicked into the path of Coutinho, who made no mistake slotting it into the bottom corner.

In contrasting fashion, Ferencvaros were very direct. It was very clear that Tokmac Nguen was their main danger-man. Nguen created a couple of really dangerous moments in the first half with his threatening runs across the backline. The first effort was called offside, while the second led to him setting up Isael for a thunderous shot against the post.

He was also at the helm of their sole goal of the game, running at Pique, who was unable to keep up with Nguen and hauled him down into the box, leading to a penalty.

Passing

Barcelona’s passing was on point against Ferencvaros, helping the team to cover all zones perfectly, stretching the pitch and making it difficult to defend. Most importantly, there were a lot more passes into the box as well exchanges inside the box than the previous two games. Particularly impressive were the utilization of zone 14 and the half-spaces. Here are the dangerous passes portrayed:

The key passes came from multiple zones as well and from multiple sources. Messi had 4, Roberto, Pjanic, Coutinho, and Fati had 2 each, while de Jong, Trincao and Dembele had 1 each:

Finally, we compare the passes completed in the final third by each team, quantified by field tilt – it’s the number of final third passes completed by a team, divided by the sum of final third passes completed by both teams, expressed as a percentage.

Barcelona completed a much greater number of final third passes almost throughout the game except for a small window when Pique received a red card and sent off for fouling Nguen, and Barcelona had to play with 10 men.

Defence

Barcelona’s defence closely resembled a 4-4-2 block with Philippe Coutinho and Lionel Messi high up, and sometimes in 4-5-1 as Messi was the sole player allowed to stay up.

After Pique’s red card, Barcelona took up a fairly compact 4-4-1 shape. Ferencvaros were pushed back into their own half for the bulk of the match as Barcelona won the ball back fairly fast. The only time Ferencvaros managed to peg back Barcelona was after Pique’s dismissal. Here is a glimpse of the defensive activities of the two teams, showing Barça’s high turnover rate:

In fact, the third goal that Barcelona scored early in the second half came from a great bit of pressing. Messi aggressively pressed the central channels into Ferencvaros’ third and the box, so the ball had to be passed out wide, where Trincao led the charge. This led to a misplaced pass that was intercepted by Pjanic, and Trincao recovered the loose ball. A lovely sequence ensued, and Barcelona were up 3-0 in a blink.

Issues

Having discussed the defensive structure and the pressing intensity, now it’s time to discuss some of the issues. In this particular game, the issues were entirely in defence. Ferencvaros – Nguen in particular – exposed the problem Barcelona’s centre backs have against quick attackers. The Norwegian’s runs dragged the defenders all over the place, mixed with the high line that Barcelona employs, it resulted in nightmares as it often does.

Whenever the fullbacks were pushed high, and possession was turned over, Ferencvaros directly took on the two defenders left on the pitch. They could not bypass the press by making long passing sequences, so they quickly circulated ball out wide or to the deep half spaces before launching long balls to Nguen, and sending out supporting runners. One such run led to Pique’s red card.

This current batch of Barcelona players seems a tad too card-happy. Lenglet has already seen a red card in the Liga. Roberto, Dest, Pique – all of them have seen yellow cards just 4 games into the season. This is not healthy, especially given the lack of quality depth in defence.

Coutinho has been playing well, to say the least, and there are little to no doubts over his performance. However, his positioning – which surely is a tactical quirk of Ronald Koeman – is very interesting. Instead of the usual central positions a nominal 10 would take up, he is primarily operating in the left half space. There is quite a bit of overlap with Ansu Fati. Its clear that Barcelona are trying to achieve wide overloads on the left side whenever they can.

Coutinho performances are not an issue. His role, on the other hand, might be. (Photo by Alex Caparros/Getty Images)

This system, however, needs a striker and more directness to function. As it stands, the team is deploying two 10s in Messi and Coutinho. While this has worked well against weaker oppositions, it remains to be seen how well the lack of vertical staggering can hold up against stronger opposition.

The Substitutes

The story of this game will be incomplete without mentioning the substitutions. Junior Firpo returned from injury and came on along with Pedri and Ousmane Dembele around the 60-minute mark. Ronald Araujo had to come on after Pique’s dismissal, while Sergio Busquets replaced Pjanic later to help see the game off.

While Pedri got his first goal for Barcelona, Dembele’s brilliant dribble and tenacity in the box from where he cut back the ball has to be mentioned. Seven minutes later, the World Cup winner found himself at the receiving end of a pass from Messi and smashed home for the fifth and final goal.

Conclusion

After the drab showing against Getafe, this was a much-needed boost for the team before the El Clasico. Multiple scorers, good buildup plays, high press – pretty much everything except the red card was to the point. Next week’s UCL away game against Juventus will prove a stern test as well, and hopefully, we will see the best of Ronald Araujo in that game.

Continue Reading

Trending Articles